Thermometers

TO DIAGNOSE NEONATAL HYPOTHERMIA and maternal fevers

Diagnostic
Diagnostic
  • PREVENTION
  • DIAGNOSTIC
  • TREATMENT
  • OVERVIEW
  • TECHNOLOGY Characteristics
  • Thermometers
    TALC ThermoSpot 12mm liquid crystal thermometer

    Condition
    The WHO defines the normal temperature of a neonate at 36.5– 37.5°C, and gradations of hypothermia including mild (36-36.5°C), moderate (32-36°C) and severe (<32°C). Even at warm ambient temperatures, neonates can have difficulty retaining heat, especially as amniotic fluid evaporates off their skin. While hypothermia kills more infants, the effects of prolonged hyperthermia can also be devastating.

     

    Thermometers are also helpful to diagnose maternal infection. A fever of greater than 100 degrees Farenheight is often indicative of an infection. Furthermore, fevers over 103 degrees can cause mental symptoms and become dangerous.

    Mechanism of Action
    Mercury and alcohol thermometers rely on the thermal expansion of liquid up a calibrated column. Digital thermometers typically rely on either a thermocouple or thermister for contact measurement. Axillary measurement is typically preferred for safety, hygiene, and ease. Tympanic thermometers detect infrared radiation from middle ear tissues and can give accurate readings in 1-2 seconds, but may be inconvenient in the immediate neonatal period if the tympanic membrane is inaccessible. Liquid crystal thermometers are usually plastic films which change color on the basis of temperature.

    Current Use in High-Resource Settings
    Digital and tympanic measurement tools are most common for spot checking neonatal temperature. Thermocouples or thermisters may be taped to the infant’s skin for continuous monitoring in intensive care settings. Digital pacifier thermometers are sometimes used in outpatient settings and as consumer products. For adults, gradations must be shown to understand the severity of the fever. Increasingly, disposable or digital thermometers are being used.

    Application in Low-Resource Settings
    The most prevalent technique to assess temperature in low-resource settings is human touch, which is typically more sensitive to hyperthermia than hypothermia. Low cost mercury thermometers are also commonly used, but are often fragile and require some degree of training.

    In infants, the WHO recommends axillary placement of such thermometers for 5 minutes or rectal placement for three minutes (whereas digital thermometers may take a reading in less time). The liquid crystal ThermoSpot has been tested in urban and rural settings in India with promising results, especially for multi-day monitoring in environments where caregivers may not be trained to use mercury thermometers.
     

    REPRESENTATIVE DEVICES

    MAKE
    MODEL
    PRICE
    TECH
    STATUS
    NOTES

    Braun

    Thermoscan
    $45
    Tympanic
    Marketed
    Measurement in 1-2 seconds

    Target

    Pacifier Thermometer
    $8
    Digital
    Marketed
    Generic consumer product

    Smith

    Level 1
    $7
    Thermocouple
    Marketed
    Thermocouple probe only

    Generic

    Alcohol thermometer
    $1.00
    Alcohol
    Marketed
    Eliminates Hg hazard

    Hallcrest

    Forehead Strips
    $0.60
    Liquid crystal
    Marketed
    Quantitative liquid crystal

    Generic

    Mercury Thermometer
    $0.50
    Mercury
    Marketed
    Standard measure, Hg hazard

    TALC

    ThermoSpot
    $0.20
    Liquid crystal
    Marketed
    Binary output, minimal training

    * Prices are approximated. Actual pricing can, and will vary by marketplace and market conditions.

  • CHARACTERISTICS OF REPRESENTATIVE PRODUCT

    TECHNOLOGY CHARACTERISTICS

    OPERATIONAL PARAMETERS

    POTENTIAL OPPORTUNITIES FOR IMPROVEMENT

    SKILLS

    REQUIRED

    Intended end user
    Training required
    Time required per use
    Nurse, mother
    Minutes
    Minutes

    The strength of the device is its simplicity, but it could be beneficial to also diagnose hyperthermia with another color change.

    ENVIRONMENT/ INFRASTRUCTURE

    Power required
    Waste collection
    Complementary technologies required
    Temperature and storage
    Maintenance
    None
    Designed to be disposable
    None
    No extreme temperatures, protected from sunlight

    In some cases, the adhesive fails, and the device is re-adhered using transparent tape.

    COST

    Device Cost (Approx)
    Cost/course (Approx)
    <$1
    <$1

    On a large scale, it would seem possible to further reduce cost.

    OTHER

    Portability
    Regulatory
    Efficacy
    <10g
    Defining hypothermia at 35°C, sensitivity 88%, specificity 97%

    Additional devices required for impact: A method of re-warming the infant, including skin to skin contact (Kangaroo Mother Care) or an infant warmer of some type

Sources: WHO Safe Motherhood. Thermal Protection of the Newborn: A Practical Guide. 1997. WHO Geneva. V. Kumar et al. Effect of community-based behaviour change management on neonatal mortality in Shivgarh, Uttar Pradesh, India: a cluster-randomised controlled trial. The Lancet. 2008: 1151-1162. C. Mullany et al. Incidence and seasonality of hypothermia among newborns in southern Nepal. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2010: 164(1): 71-77. D. Green et al. Neonatal hypothermia detection by ThermoSpot in Indian urban slum dwellings. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed. 2006 March; 91(2): F96–F98. D. Morley et al. A neonatal hypothermia indicator. Lancet 2000: 659